When You Recover at Different Speeds After a Fight
Making Up and Recovering Are Two Different Things
You've made up in words, but one of you is fine right away while the other feels heavy for a day or two. Making up ends with a conversation, but recovery comes at each person's own pace. Here are the traits that set recovery speed, and how two people with different speeds can wait for each other.
The “you” in this story, is it really you? See my Social & Private self · free →
You had a big argument in the evening, and after about an hour of talking it through, you both apologized. “I'm sorry, I went too far.” “I'm sorry too.” But the next morning, one of you sends a playful message like usual. The other looks at it and hesitates for a long time, not sure how to reply. It's not that there's anger left, but they're not in the mood to laugh yet. As the reply takes a while, the one who sent the message starts wondering too: “We sorted it all out yesterday. Are they still mad?”
Sometimes the time after a fight is more awkward than the fight itself. In this piece, let's talk about why making up and recovering come at different speeds, the traits that set recovery speed, and how two people with different speeds can wait for each other without a second fight.
Making up ends in words, and recovery comes separately
Making up usually happens in conversation. You say what hurt, you apologize, and you agree on what to do next time. This is something the you around people is good at. It's about facing the other person, choosing your words, and reaching a conclusion.
Recovery happens somewhere else. It's the time after the conversation ends, when the you when alone slowly digests everything that was said that day. A sentence you heard may come back to you, or the tail end of the hurt may linger for a while. For some people, this digesting finishes almost at the same moment as the conversation, and for others, it only starts once the conversation is over.
So “We made up, so why are you still like this?” means the two of you are looking at different clocks. One is looking at the clock for making up, the other at the clock for recovering.
The one who recovers slowly can misread themselves, too. If they still feel heavy after making up, they start doubting themselves: “Does this mean I still haven't forgiven them?” But forgiving and digesting are different things. The forgiving is already done. The digesting just isn't finished yet.
The clash in the middle of a fight, between “Let's settle this now” and “Let's talk later,” is covered separately in When the Anxious and the Avoidant Meet. This piece is about what comes after, once the conversation has already ended.
The traits that set recovery speed
Emotional amplitude. People with a wide amplitude feel big emotions in a fight, and the ripples last just as long. They may spend a day or so in a state where their head understands but their heart is still catching up. People with a narrow amplitude get back to normal quickly, since the emotions never rose that high to begin with.
Accommodating. People high on Accommodating find it hard to stay in an awkward place with someone for long. So they sometimes act like everything is normal before they've actually recovered. They may look fast on the outside while still sorting things out inside.
Organized. People high on Organized close the matter once there's a conclusion. If you agreed on it, it's done, and they feel there's no reason to bring it up again. On the other hand, some people can't feel settled, even once a conclusion is reached, as long as there's a single knot still caught in their mind. They need that knot untied first.
Social. People high on Social feel better quickly when they're with someone, so right after making up they want to do something together. People low on Social need time alone to sort out their feelings, so right after making up they'd actually rather keep a little distance. Because of this difference, one person reaching out can feel like pressure to the other.
On top of this comes the gap between your social self and your private self. Someone who pulls themselves together quickly around people may chew on things for a long time when alone. A partner is someone who sees both sides, so the calm you showed during yesterday's talk and today's heaviness look like two different things, which makes it even more confusing.
In short, recovery speed has more to do with a person's traits than with the size of the fight. When a fight of the same size is over quickly one day and takes a long time another day, it's because that day's tiredness or circumstances got added in. Recovering at different speeds doesn't mean you care by different amounts.
The day after making up: what each of you is really thinking
| Moment | The one who recovers fast | The one who recovers slowly |
|---|---|---|
| Texting the next morning | If I talk like usual, everything will be fine | I don't have room for jokes yet |
| A short reply from the other person | They must still be mad | I'm not mad, just low on energy |
| Bringing up yesterday again | Why bring up something that's settled? | It's one piece I'm still digesting |
| Touch or jokes | Getting close helps me feel better fast | I need a little more time to feel at ease |
Neither column in the table is wrong. The trouble starts when you don't know the other person's column and read their speed by your own. To the one who recovers fast, the other's heaviness looks like a sign they're still angry, and to the one who recovers slowly, the other's lightness looks like the fight was no big deal. The moment you misread each other's speed like that, a small fight gets piled on top of the one that's already over. “How can you already be laughing?” and “Are you still on about that?” usually come from right here.
Five ways for two people with different speeds to wait for each other
- Tell them your speed in words. If you're the one who recovers slowly, just say one line: “I'm not mad, my heart's just still catching up.” What the other person most wants to know is whether you're still angry. That one line heads off a second fight. If you're the one who recovers fast, ask the opposite: “I'm feeling okay now. How about you?” It's not a question to check up on them, but a question that leaves the door open.
- Add a rough arrival time. “I think I'll be okay by this evening.” It doesn't have to be exact. When the end is in sight, the one waiting feels less anxious too. If you still feel heavy once that time has passed, just let them know again: “It's taking a little longer than I thought.”
- If you've already bounced back, stay close but don't rush them. Instead of asking “Are you still mad?” over and over, say, “I'm okay now. You can take your time.” Being there for someone and pushing them to be okay quickly are two different things. It's also good to ask first whether a little closeness, like holding hands or eating together, feels okay.
- Save leftover pieces for a set day. If there's one piece that gets stuck while you're digesting, don't carry it straight back into a fight. Write it down instead. A couple of days later, when you're both calm, bring it up with “Can we talk again about just one thing that was said that day?” and it will be over much faster. While it sits on paper, you'll often find that plenty of those pieces were no big deal after all.
- Agree on a recovery signal ahead of time. In calmer moments, agree on a small signal that says “I'm all better now.” Something like bringing home their favorite snack, or being the first to suggest a walk. That way you can signal that you've recovered even when saying it out loud feels awkward. It works best if the one who recovers slowly is the one who sends the signal. The one waiting can relax a little until it comes, and the one recovering can come back when they're ready.
Don't read it this way
- It doesn't mean people who recover slowly hold grudges. Their hearts just need time to digest. They're not trying to punish anyone.
- It doesn't mean people who recover fast take things lightly, either. Many of them simply want to get the relationship back to normal as soon as they can.
- Recovering at different speeds doesn't mean you're a bad match. The fast one warms the relationship back up, and the slow one mulls things over so the same fight doesn't keep repeating. Once you know each other's speed, the awkward stretch after a fight actually gets shorter.
- If every fight involves one of you belittling the other or saying things meant to frighten them, that's not a matter of recovery speed. Please look first at whether you're safe in that relationship.
Wrapping up
Just because the fight is over doesn't mean your hearts get there at the same moment. You make up together, but you each recover at your own pace. Once you know that difference, “Why aren't you over it yet?” turns into “Take your time.” After the next fight, start by asking each other where your clocks are.
The free personality test shows the you around people and the you when alone on five personality traits, separately. Put your Emotional and Accommodating results side by side with your partner's, and you can see who comes back first after a fight and who stays a little longer.
This piece is meant to help you understand yourself and is not a diagnosis that defines your relationship.
The “you” in this story, is it really you?
See my Social & Private self · freeFree · Start without sign-up