32personas
Public & private self

The You That Changes Only Around Your Parents

Why You Swing Between Irritation and Guilt

Calm and grown up everywhere else, but curt only with your parents, and then sorry on the way home? We look at the gap between the you your parents remember and the you of today, how their worry reaches your private self, and ways to cut down on the swing between irritation and guilt.

The “you” in this story, is it really you? See my Social & Private self · free →

It's the day you go back to your parents' place for the first time in a month. On the way there, you promise yourself you'll be sweet this time. When you open the front door, your mom greets you happily and says, “Why do you look so worn out? Are you eating properly?” At the dinner table, the questions keep coming: Is work going okay? Are you seeing anyone? Your answers get shorter and shorter, until finally you snap, “Ugh, I'll handle it myself.” On the train home, looking out the window, your heart feels heavy. “That really wasn't worth saying like that.”

Plenty of people are calm, polite adults out in the world but become someone else only in front of their parents. We covered why a different you comes out in each relationship in A Different Me Pops Out With Different People. This piece zooms in on one place in particular, being in front of your parents, and talks about why irritation and guilt go back and forth there especially, and how you can cut down on that back-and-forth.

Your parents are talking to the younger you

The you your parents have seen the longest isn't the you of today. It's the child who needed to be fed, the student coming home with a report card, the new hire nervous before the first day at work. So your parents' words keep aiming at the you from those days. That's why, even when you're past thirty, “Have you eaten?” is the first thing out of their mouths.

Out in the world, you've spent a long time building the adult you are now. Someone who sets their own schedule, deals with problems, and gets by without anyone looking after them. But in front of your parents, that version doesn't quite work. In the gap between the you your parents remember and the you of today, old reactions pop out before you know it.

The truth is, your parents don't know the you of today very well either. If you've lived apart for a long time, what they know of your daily life may be nothing more than a few phone calls and a few short visits. They fill in the parts they don't know with old memories. So their worry, too, comes out in a shape that fits the younger you.

You're not the only one who changes. Parents also become someone different in front of their children than they are out in the world. Someone who keeps quiet about other people's business at gatherings will ask about and fuss over every little thing when it comes to their own child. It's a place where both of you slip back into your old roles, so you both feel awkward but can't easily get out of it.

Their worry goes straight to your private self

There's one more reason your parents' questions sting so much. Questions about whether work is okay, whether you're saving money, whether you're seeing anyone, are usually worries you've already chewed over countless times on your own. Out in the world, no one asks, so you could act like everything is fine. Your parents bring those very worries up head-on, out of how much they care about you.

So the irritation is often aimed less at the question than at the worry it touched. That's also why the guilt follows. Once you're alone on the way home, it's plain to see that your parents were only worried about you.

The reaction is especially big for worries you haven't found an answer to yet. If it's a problem you've already settled, you can answer calmly even when your parents ask. So if you look at which questions set off the biggest irritation, you can also see which worry you've been holding onto the longest inside lately. The irritation is often less a feeling about your parents than a signal of how big that worry is.

Four versions of you that come out around your parents

You around your parentsWhat's happening insideOne thing to try
The curt youTheir worry sounds like interference, so defensiveness comes out firstGive a short update before the questions start
The good-kid youYou pick only the good news so you won't disappoint themShare one small worry just as it is
The quiet youYou're not sure how to be, so you go quietFind one thing to do together
The kid-again youThey take care of you, so it's easy to leave everything to themPick one household chore to take on

Which version shows up most depends on your traits. People high on Accommodating easily slip into the good-kid you, since they quickly read their parents' expectations and match them. People with a wide emotional amplitude get shaken hard by even a small remark, so they easily become the curt you. People high on Organized, used to their own tidy way of living, can get prickly over small things when they run into the different way things are done at their parents' place. People low on Social often get through days when the relatives gather, too, by becoming the quiet you. People high on Inquisitive often choose a path that's different from everyone else's, so they wear out quickly in front of questions that make them explain those choices.

The four versions can also take turns within one person. You might be the good kid at lunch and turn curt by dinner. Knowing which version shows up most often tells you what to prepare for first.

Five ways to cut down on the swing between irritation and guilt

  1. Give a short update first. If you speak first, before the questions pour in, the same things sting less. “Work's busy lately, but I'm fine. I'm eating well, too.” You go from being the one who gets questioned to being the one who shares the news. If there's a topic that especially gets to you, it also helps to prepare a one-sentence update on it before you go.
  2. When you'd like them to stop asking, give a reason. “I'm still sorting that out, so once I've figured it out, you'll be the first to know.” Instead of cutting them off curtly, you're letting them know it's hard to talk about right now. When they know you're not hiding it but still working it out, your parents worry less too. If they ask again, just gently repeat the same sentence once more.
  3. Show them one piece of the you of today at a time. Cook them a dish you've been making a lot lately, or tell them about something new you've learned. It can be something small, like music you've been listening to or a workout you've been doing. You're painting the you of today, bit by bit, over the younger you they remember. The more they get to know the you of today, the less they'll keep talking to the younger you.
  4. Match how long you stay to your traits. If you're low on Social, spending a relaxed half day may be better for everyone than packing the whole weekend. Shorter visits more often are another option. If you tell them ahead of time, before you arrive, “I'll head out after dinner this time,” it will sting less when you get up to leave early.
  5. Smooth things over with one line on the way home. If it's weighing on you that you were curt, send a short message from the train. “I was a bit short with you earlier. Thanks for worrying about me.” Rather than chewing on the guilt, set it down in one line, and the next visit will feel lighter. If a message feels awkward, a single line on your next call is enough: “I was a little curt last time, wasn't I?”

Don't read it this way

  • It doesn't mean the you that changes around your parents is fake. That version is also a side of you, shaped by a long relationship.
  • It doesn't mean you always have to be sweet to your parents, either. It's okay to have days when you keep your answers short. The point is to work on it when the swings happen so often that you're worn out too.
  • It doesn't mean you have to tell them everything, either. It's natural for grown children to keep some parts of their lives to themselves.
  • If conversations with your parents always end in hurt, or you feel like you fall apart for a long time after seeing them, it may be a problem that goes beyond a difference in traits. In that case, keeping some distance and seeing a counselor are both ways to protect yourself.

Wrapping up

The you that changes only around your parents shows up in the place where the you they remember meets the you of today. It makes sense that this place feels awkward. One side remembers the younger you, and the other is living as the you of today. On your next visit, rather than straining to hold back the irritation, try showing them just one piece of the you of today. As those pieces add up, the you your parents know gets a little closer to the you of today.

The free personality test shows the you around people and the you when alone on five personality traits, separately. Seeing where you land on Accommodating and Emotional in each of those two situations shows which version of you tends to come out around your parents.

This piece is meant to help you understand yourself and does not replace psychological diagnosis or treatment.

Enjoyed this story?

The “you” in this story, is it really you?

See my Social & Private self · free

Free · Start without sign-up